Livvy Dunne Says Co-op Board Denied Her Bid for Babe Ruths Former Home

There was no attempt by Livvy Dunne to twist it. On July 8, she made it clear in a TikTok post: I’m really angry. It’s hardly what you would expect to hear about her first apartment from a 22-year-old billionaire influencer.

However, this flat wasn’t your typical one. It used to be Babe Ruth’s famous $1.59 million co-op apartment at 345 West 88th Street on New York’s Upper West Side. Even if you walk in with cash, it’s still out of reach despite being historic and exclusive.

Livvy declared herself prepared. Paul Skenes, an MLB pitcher and her boyfriend, took her on a tour of the facility. The real estate agent exuded confidence. Since it would be illegal to transport my dorm room furnishings to Babe Ruth’s residence, she even arranged for an interior designer.

The phone call then arrived.

The co-op board rejected her just a few days before she was due to receive her keys. No justification. Simply said, no. Livvy kept it light, asking if her LSU connections were disliked by the Alabama supporters on the board. The sting, however, was genuine.

You can understand the emotion if you’ve ever been turned down for a house even if everything was in order. It hits differently when you multiply it by the millions of followers who are following every move you make.

What does she want her admirers to know? Avoid attempting to live in a cooperative. You may be turned away. Additionally, Babe Ruth’s apartment is not yours. brutal. Sincere. And the sort of reality check that most influencers in the real estate industry won’t give you.

Do you believe that co-op boards have the right to turn away buyers who have qualifications and money? Or is this simply New York acting in the same way as always? Let’s discuss in the comments section.

Why Did the Co-op Board Say No?

You’re not incorrect if you’ve ever believed that money talks in real estate, particularly in New York City. Even a full monetary offer, however, may not always be enough to get you past the door. Livvy experienced precisely that.

She wasn’t only looking around. The New York Post claims that Livvy made a significant move by scouting the space with Paul Skenes, having funds on hand, and having a designer on board. Everything appeared to be locked in.

The co-op board abruptly shut it down, though. No explanation was provided. No comments. A simple rejection.

This may sound crazy to those who are not from New York. However, boards in Manhattan cooperatives have the authority to reject you for virtually any reason, and they are not even required to provide an explanation. Everything is on the line, including your salary, lifestyle, mood, and media attention. They also don’t have to explain why they said no.

That’s the harsh truth. You might be well-known, rich, and prepared to write a check right now. It doesn’t matter. The transaction is off if the board does not think you are a fit.

Celebrities like Madonna and even A-Rod have been turned away, and I have witnessed this happen previously. Livvy isn’t the first, then. However, when a 22-year-old influencer enters with fresh ideas and is rejected by traditional gatekeepers, it does strike a different chord.

This should cause you to reconsider your plans to own a co-op in the future. It’s more important to consider whether people like you than what you have.

There are difficulties even for celebrities who choose condos.The price of Amy Schumer’s Brooklyn property is only one illustration of how erratic the NYC real estate market can be.

What Made This Apartment So Special, Anyway?

Was this location truly worth all the commotion, you ask? Yes, is the response. And not only due to the place.

This wasn’t just any pad on the Upper West Side, according to People. In fact, Babe Ruth resided there for 20 years, from 1920 to 1940. Not rented. No, not in the past. At one time, he and his family controlled the entire structure.

New York doesn’t frequently have that kind of history. You’re purchasing legacy rather than just real estate.

Livvy was obviously feeling it. She was ecstatic, almost sentimental. She shared in her TikTok how she was telling everyone about it: The gag was, it was Babe Ruth s apartment. I’m informing everyone, of course.

I don’t hold her accountable. Imagine taking first place, and it just so happens to be associated with one of baseball’s greatest legends. You would also be shouting it from the roofs.

She was receiving three bedrooms in a historic building on a peaceful street with trees for $1.59 million. Not dazzling. Not too big. but significant. And that’s why the rejection hurts even more.

Just likeJoy Mangano s 18,000 sq. ft Long Island home, some properties carry legacies that go beyond bricks and mortar.

What This Means for Livvy s Brand?

Let’s be honest. Livvy s not going to be homeless. But public rejection always carries PR weight. And in this case, I actually think it worked in her favor.

She came across as honest, self-aware, and down-to-earth. No fake luxury, no I m better than this attitude. Just a 22-year-old saying, I was excited, I got denied, and it sucks.

That kind of transparency builds trust. If you re someone who follows influencers, you know how rare it is for them to admit something didn t work out. Most people just disappear the moment things go sideways.

For Livvy, this could actually open more doors. Think about it home design brands, condo developers, even NYC lifestyle platforms might want to collaborate with her now that she s proven she s trying to plant roots.

As for you? If you re trying to build a brand on TikTok, YouTube, or anywhere remember this: moments of failure are sometimes more powerful than wins. People remember how you handle disappointment more than how you flex.

Reactions like these often spread faster on closed platforms too some group chats and WhatsApp channels were already sharing memes about it before it hit the news cycle.

Should You Even Try Buying a Co-op in NYC? Let s Talk Reality

If you ve never dealt with NYC real estate, let me break it down for you co-ops are an entirely different game.

Unlike condos, where you buy your unit outright, co-ops make you buy into a corporation that owns the building. You don t just sign papers you apply like it s a job. Financials, interviews, references, background checks the whole thing.

Even if you can afford it, you still need the board s blessing. And they can reject you for anything that doesn t fit the building s culture.

That s probably what happened to Livvy. She s young, high-profile, and constantly online. For an old-money Upper West Side co-op, that s not always a great combo.

Now, if you re looking to buy in NYC, don t let this scare you but be prepared. Co-ops are often cheaper than condos, but they come with a price: control. If you want more flexibility, go condo. If you want charm, history, and tight rules, go co-op but keep your expectations in check.

And no, it s not just influencers who get turned down. Plenty of regular folks do too. It s just that when Livvy gets rejected, the whole internet hears about it.

It s not just Livvy celeb couples likeAdam Levine and Behati Prinsloo s Montecito estateare hitting the market too, showing how real estate moves are just as much about branding as location.

What s Next for Livvy? And Where Could She Go Now?

Just because Livvy didn t get Babe Ruth s apartment doesn t mean the NYC dream is over. Far from it.

Honestly, this might push her toward something even better. Condos in neighborhoods like Tribeca or SoHo offer more privacy, modern layouts, and most importantly no co-op board to block you. For someone with her lifestyle and visibility, that might be a blessing.

She s also got the attention of the real estate world now. Don t be surprised if developers or luxury agents start approaching her for brand partnerships or exclusive walkthroughs. Sometimes, getting denied from one door opens five new ones.

If you re someone who s been turned away or hit a wall while house-hunting, don t take it personally. Whether you re Livvy Dunne or a first-time buyer with a tight budget real estate has a way of humbling you. But there s always a plan B. And sometimes, plan B is better.

Final Thoughts

There s something kind of poetic about this whole situation. A young, successful woman tries to buy a legendary baseball player s apartment and gets blocked by a bunch of people she s never met.

It s funny. It s frustrating. And it s very, very New York.

But Livvy handled it the best way possible: with humor, honesty, and zero ego. That s rare in this world, and it s probably why so many people ended up rooting for her even more.

So if you ve ever felt like your money, effort, or excitement wasn t enough this story s for you. Fame doesn t guarantee access. Sometimes, rejection makes you more relatable than any win ever could.

What would you have done in Livvy s shoes fought it, laughed it off, or gone even bigger? Drop a comment below I m curious what you think.

If stories like this interest you, you might enjoy browsing ourCelebrity Home Securitysection real estate isn t always about square footage, sometimes it s about who gets in and who gets locked out.

Disclaimer:This article is based on publicly available information, including Livvy Dunne s own social media posts. Any speculation around co-op board decisions is presented for context only. We do not claim to represent Livvy Dunne or the co-op board s official stance.

Table of Contents

• Livvy Dunne Says Co-op Board Denied Her Bid for Babe Ruths Former Home

  • Why Did the Co-op Board Say No?

  • What Made This Apartment So Special, Anyway?

  • What This Means for Livvy s Brand?

  • Should You Even Try Buying a Co-op in NYC? Let s Talk Reality

  • What s Next for Livvy? And Where Could She Go Now?

  • Final Thoughts

• Why Did the Co-op Board Say No?

• What Made This Apartment So Special, Anyway?

• What This Means for Livvy s Brand?

• Should You Even Try Buying a Co-op in NYC? Let s Talk Reality

• What s Next for Livvy? And Where Could She Go Now?

• Final Thoughts